PDA

View Full Version : If you are a die hard Beatles fan...



T_Totler
09-09-2009, 06:19 PM
...then this collection is for you :)


The folks at Apple Corps and EMI – the empire the Beatles built – certainly know their stuff.

With the CD format in its final throes, they're making one last effort to convince music fans that their new boxed set of the entire Beatles back catalogue, available today for the first time in painstakingly remastered, digitized stereo, will make all your old Beatles recordings obsolete; and that the $300 asking price for the 13 studio albums, plus double CD of non-album, extended-play and alternative cuts, as well as a DVD of mini-documentaries with rare footage, voice-overs and photographs, is a small sacrifice for such a noble and exhaustingly complete post-modern masterpiece.

They're right on the money, of course. The new Beatles boxed set is a wonderful thing, containing some 217 songs repolished to crystalline perfection and reformatted deferentially into two audio channels without, for the most part, diminishing the enduring charm and excitement of the original versions of the songs, most of which were mixed and released in the single channel format, the standard format 40 years ago.

For subsequent generations who've grown up in a stereo world this set may be something of a revelation.

The songs do have additional dimension and clarity, with each sound ascribed a distinct position in the stereo spectrum. Musicians and hi-fi perfectionists may actually be able to hear the click of a plectrum on George Harrison's steel guitar strings, the spittle frothing at the end of Paul McCartney's tongue, the sardonic sneer that shapes John Lennon's vowels and even the occasional squeak of Ringo's bass drum pedal.

They will also hear succinct evidence of each player's individual technique: little errors in timing and quirks of musical judgment that were buried in the mono mixes for the greater good of the song.

And with the stylish extras – each album comes with a booklet featuring the original art work, liner notes, extra photographs and historical data about the recording – it's no surprise that Amazon.com has already sold out its original pre-release allotment and is taking back orders for future delivery.

The Beatles' marketers have been particularly cunning, however, by banking on the belief that high-end audiophile consumers, collectors and true Beatles fans will eschew the stereo jiggery pokery for a boxed set of the Beatles' 10 original mono albums (up to and including The White Album) cleaned up, digitized and remastered in glorious mono. It's on sale today too.

Again, they're on the money. The Beatles in Mono set, featuring miniaturized exact replicas of the original covers and artwork, costs about $100 more than the stereo collection and is selling twice as fast.

No surprise, really. To use one musical wag's analogy, listening to the mono set is like dipping into fresh, organic guacamole. Listening to the stereo set is akin to being served a dish of chemically enhanced avocados, tomatoes, onions, lime and salt, and a mortar and pestle. Make of it what you will, but it probably won't taste like the real thing.Source (http://www.thestar.com/entertainment/music/article/692701)

Lee Anne
09-10-2009, 12:35 AM
Bought both sets on Tuesday, had them pre-ordered for quite awhile.

Quicksilver
09-10-2009, 09:43 PM
Good going Lee Anne!
I so wanted the mono set.
And you had them pre-ordered for quite awhile as well?
I didn't see or hear anything about them being reissued!

Lee Anne
09-10-2009, 11:00 PM
We actually pre-ordered them at HMV last week when I found the price was cheaper than Amazon, the girl at HMV said they sold out within a half hour but you may want to call your nearest location to see if you can order the mono set or check the site to see which locations may have it in stock.

HMV:
Stereo Box = $189.99
Mono Box - $219.99

Right now we're only a few albums into the stereo box, going to be a looong time before we finish hearing everything.

Limey32
09-10-2009, 11:38 PM
Ahahahaha. I'm waiting for a new release of the Beach Boys myself. Seriously? I am British, and love the Beatles, but there is no way on Earth I would pay for their music again. You must be some die hard fans or something...... else. :)

Lee Anne
09-11-2009, 01:32 AM
So it's worth it to some and not others.

There's quite a few songs in true stereo that were echo chambers or other forms of fake stereo and the mono set is certaintly interesting as it has versions of songs from Rarities which were never put on Cd as well as other recordings which are a treat to hear, just interesting stuff to the die hard Beatle fan :)

Limey32
09-11-2009, 02:35 AM
I know, and I was only teasing. :) If you have both the ear and the equipment to tell the difference.. so be it. Personally, the songs on mp3 are more than sufficient. "A taste of honey" can only sound so good. I don't need to hear every last cord intact. Certainly not for that kind of coin.

Quicksilver
09-11-2009, 08:15 AM
We actually pre-ordered them at HMV last week when I found the price was cheaper than Amazon, the girl at HMV said they sold out within a half hour but you may want to call your nearest location to see if you can order the mono set or check the site to see which locations may have it in stock.

HMV:
Stereo Box = $189.99
Mono Box - $219.99

Right now we're only a few albums into the stereo box, going to be a looong time before we finish hearing everything.

That's a good idea to check my local, now why didn't I think of that, thanks Lee Anne!

T_Totler
09-11-2009, 08:23 AM
I know, and I was only teasing. :) If you have both the ear and the equipment to tell the difference.. so be it. Personally, the songs on mp3 are more than sufficient. "A taste of honey" can only sound so good. I don't need to hear every last cord intact. Certainly not for that kind of coin.
I wouldn't consider myself a die hard Beatles fan, but I have a lot of their music in various formats (vinyl, cassette, CD's) so I might buy it just so that I have all their music together, in a single format.

The size of this compilation goes to show just how extensive their body of work was.

Quicksilver
09-11-2009, 08:31 AM
If you have both the ear and the equipment to tell the difference.. so be it. Personally, the songs on mp3 are more than sufficient. "A taste of honey" can only sound so good. I don't need to hear every last cord intact. Certainly not for that kind of coin.


I have the gear "High End Audio" and the ear to tell the difference!
If you listen to an analog & CD recording you would be surprised! :)

Mouse
09-11-2009, 08:38 AM
I've heard enough Beatles, during the hype, to last me quite a while. ;)

BillD
09-11-2009, 08:44 AM
I have the gear "High End Audio" and the ear to tell the difference!
If you listen to an analog & CD recording you would be surprised! :)

Which do you prefer? Many audiophiles I know prefer the analog, claiming the digital sound is too"clean", with little things missing.

T_Totler
09-11-2009, 08:49 AM
Many audiophiles I know prefer the analog, claiming the digital sound is too"clean", with little things missing.
I'm one of those. In fact, I still find that vinyl provides a "warmer" sound than CD's. For example, I prefer to listen to Pink Floyd's Dark Side of The Moon album on vinyl rather than CD.

SPARKY
09-11-2009, 11:33 AM
I'm one of those. In fact, I still find that vinyl provides a "warmer" sound than CD's. For example, I prefer to listen to Pink Floyd's Dark Side of The Moon album on vinyl rather than CD.

Ditto, Dark Side of The Moon is a good example, vinyl all the way, I have nice equipment and speakers, I can tell the sound difference between a record and a CD.
But my truck doesn't have a record player, so CD's come in handy, MP3's are even more convenient when cutting the grass ECT...

Bob Dobalina
09-12-2009, 06:47 PM
Here is a link to a very humerous review of the box sets :
http://www.avclub.com/articles/chuck-klosterman-repeats-the-beatles,32560/

Mouse
09-12-2009, 07:10 PM
I loved Otis, on Sanford & Son. :D

http://www.mije.org/files/u426/mug_otis_sanford_0.jpg

Lee Anne
09-12-2009, 11:09 PM
Got through the stereo set and now working on the mono, is very interesting the differences between the two, The White Album has been the biggest mono treat so far .. Blackbird, Piggies, Helter Skelter, Don't pass me by, Happiness is a warm gun .. differences in each one. Have also found a few songs which appeared on 'Rarities' :)

Still a lot of stuff to listen to so better 'get back' (Um, no pun intended there, well yeah maybe lol) to it ;)

Mouse
09-13-2009, 10:54 AM
Dave must be in his glory, but it's way too much for Mouse. ;)